For many years, we have been running a project to feed wintering birds in the wild, which are in dire need of a food base. Every year, thousands of people from all over the country participate in our work!
To avoid harming nature, we make nutritious grain balls that are safe for ecosystems, leave no waste, and can provide the necessary sustenance for wintering birds.
In my methodological guide, I briefly touched on the topic of bread for birds and highlighted the main conclusions for those who will follow the guide:
Black bread can be dangerous specifically for small forest birds.
White bread is not dangerous, but it is better to give it only in a dried form.
- Fresh bread (especially in large quantities) is not recommended due to the lack of beneficial nutrients for birds.
The main conclusion is that bread can be used as a binder in the same grain balls, but in small doses and with the addition of other components.
The conclusions are based on the opinions of ornithologists worldwide: bread is not good food for birds, but when used correctly (dried, in small doses, with additives), it does not pose a deadly threat.
Yet, there has long been a myth in society that birds should not be fed bread at all! This myth is a "duckling syndrome"—a cognitive bias effect where a person becomes attached to the first object or experience they encounter. Simply put: whatever they first heard "somewhere," they take as the truth. Moreover, "duckling syndrome" usually manifests in the rejection of other alternatives, even if they are more convenient and objective.
With feeding birds bread, it's precisely a widespread "duckling syndrome" in society.
So, is bread harmful?
As I mentioned earlier, white bread can be fed to birds, but rye bread can indeed be dangerous for forest birds. The fact is that rye bread contains many acids (especially lactic and acetic), which cause fermentation. These acids can cause digestive disorders in birds, as their digestive systems are not adapted to digesting acidic food.
Moreover, when rye bread enters a bird's stomach, it begins to ferment. This leads to bloating, pain, and potentially fatal outcomes (again, in extreme rarity, but if there's a chance—it's better not to risk it)..
But as for white bread—it's a myth! Birds can be fed with it. Such bread does not provide them with significant nutritional value, but it is certainly not dangerous.
Here is a comment from Ilgizar Rakhimov, head of the Department of Bioecology at the Institute of Fundamental Medicine and Biology of Kazan Federal University:
"We don't know of a single case where birds have died from eating bread. What absurdity is it to say that birds can't be fed bread? Bread is a grain product. For birds that eat seeds and grains, like sparrows and pigeons, bread is a normal food. They peck at the bread, and everything is fine. Not a single duck fed bread at Bulak or Kaban has died from choking on it. Where did this myth come from? It's better to give bread crumbs so the birds don't die from cold and hunger than to give them nothing at all."
This is the correct opinion of a competent specialist who knows exactly what they are talking about.
Here are the comments from Nina Sadykova, a candidate of biological sciences, research associate at the Institute of Ecology and Evolution of the Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, and a member of the Ural Ornithological Society:
"Many materials circulating on the internet about feeding ducks contain several fundamental biological errors and have given rise to a persistent but largely unfounded myth that bread is harmful to wild urban ducks. This myth is widespread not only in Russia. It seems its source is a 2008 statement by some members of the famous British Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, claiming that bread is not the most beneficial food for ducks."
It should be understood that the United Kingdom is a 'country of victorious birdwatching,' where almost all residents are bird enthusiasts and experts. The scale of feeding wild birds there is incomparable to that in Russia, and there is a well-developed industry providing bird lovers with everything necessary to attract and observe birds, including 'proper' feeding mixes. The published statement in no way suggests the need to limit feeding wild birds with bread or that bread harms wild birds.
There have been no facts, past or present, proving that bread can be harmful to wild ducks.
If ducks truly couldn't digest bread and crackers, which have been and continue to be the basis of their diet in cities during winter for at least the past 100 years, urban populations of waterfowl would have long disappeared. But this is not happening. On the contrary, they are growing everywhere.
The specialist also mentions black bread:
"I don't know where the idea of the deadly 'stomach swelling' [from black bread] came from. Perhaps something similar sometimes happens with domestic birds if they are fed only dry bread or other highly swelling products, like peas, in a coop. But for wild urban ducks, the chance of dying from this is unlikely."
Here our opinions also converge! When I tell readers about the need to exclude black bread from birds' diets, I am specifically referring to forest birds, for whom it can be dangerous.
There is a difference in the perception of black bread between forest birds and waterfowl (ducks, swans, geese) due to differences in their digestive systems.
Forest birds (tits, sparrows, woodpeckers, and others) have a short intestine and a very fast metabolism. They mainly feed on seeds, insects, and berries, and their stomachs are not adapted to digest heavy, acidic, and hard-to-dissolve food.
I carefully studied the data from the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds in Britain — indeed, in 2008 they urged people not to feed birds bread, but only because of its low energy value. The following year, they released a guide encouraging the use of bread, but in small quantities.
Their main requests were specifically that people not feed birds only bread, but try to provide a variety of nutritious foods.
The primary concern of ornithologists is usually that people throw moldy, spoiled bread to the birds! And this is what poses the greatest and most real danger: spoiled products harm humans, birds, and all other animals, just like spoiled grains, seeds, and other types of feed.
I will quote the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB):
"Birds can digest all types of bread, but ideally, it should be just one component of a varied diet. Bread does not contain the necessary proteins and fats for birds, so it may end up as an empty filler in the stomach. Although bread is not harmful to birds, try not to give it in large quantities, as its nutritional value is relatively low."
But the myth that birds should not be given bread spread across global media, and people began to believe it as a reliable scientific fact. It reached the point where people stopped feeding birds altogether, leading to real bird deaths even within city limits—from starvation during cold spells.
For instance, in 2019, the British swan protection organization Swan Support made several publications urging people to reconsider and not stop helping birds!
Their publication appeared in major international media, particularly in Edinburgh Live (part of a media group including giants like Mirror, Daily Express, Daily Star, and other major publications), with an article titled "Please keep feeding swans bread," experts plead, as birds die following a viral campaign claiming it is harmful to them."
Let me provide a few quotes:
"The official royal swan keeper, David Barber, stated that there are 'no strong reasons' not to feed swans bread and that many of them suffer from underweight due to the ban."
"Charities are documenting the heartbreaking consequences of this misguided campaign, finding more and more swans severely underweight or dead from starvation, including in Edinburgh."
"Unfortunately, another swan has suffered due to the 'ban bread' campaign. It was severely underweight, weighing only 4 kg. When our rescuers arrived, they were met by several local residents who said they had been told to stop feeding the swans bread."
"It died of starvation. It died on the way. The lake it was on has little natural food, and they depend on being fed by people."
"Please, if you have always fed them bread, please do not stop, it is better than nothing. We are publishing this not to argue. We are simply stating the facts."
"Swans have been fed bread for many hundreds of years, and it has not caused any negative consequences. Although bread may not be the best dietary option for swans compared to their natural food like river algae, it has become a very important energy source for them, supplementing their natural diet and helping them survive the cold winter months when vegetation is scarce."
I will also mention an interesting scientific study conducted in 2016 by veterinary scientists from Amsterdam. I studied it several years ago! The scientists found that 68% of all bird feed from city dwellers is bread.
The study is called "The dietary consequences of feeding free-living birds in public urban areas."
I liked their work; the specialists there were very competent, investigating not only the impact of feeding on bird health but also how it affects species diversity. The study itself was conducted specifically on urban street birds, those that live close to humans.
There was a misconception in Britain that feeding bread to swans deforms their wings. In fact, several people wrote to me about this. On November 13, 2018, The Swan Sanctuary published an official statement by David Barber, responsible for the royal swans of Great Britain, debunking the myth. This statement was supported by Oxford professor Christopher Perrins, who pointed out that there is no evidence linking bread feeding to wing deformities. Such a condition is indeed observed in young swans that have never received bread at all.
As you can see, 'myths build on myths,' and this spreads so widely that even top specialists and science professors find it difficult to explain the real facts.
These are the conclusions of scientists and experts in bird protection.
So, a little bread is better than letting birds starve to death. The main thing is that it should be accompanied by nutritious products, preferably the birds' natural food. Also, as I mentioned in my methodological guide, it's important to provide birds with a SUPPLEMENT, not to fully supply them with food, otherwise, they may become accustomed and refuse to forage in their natural habitat.
That's why we place our feeder balls randomly in the wild, imitating the natural biological rhythms—the complexity of ecosystems! Our feeder balls are 'caches' for birds and small animals, helping them survive the frosty winter.
LET'S SUMMARIZE
Thus, comrades, bread can be used to feed birds and there is no danger from the product. Warnings from ornithologists are generally related to overfeeding, when there are no other nutritious products besides bread, or the use of spoiled products. Also, for feeding forest birds, I definitely recommend completely excluding black rye bread due to the peculiarities of the digestive system of forest birds.
I have encountered statements from inexperienced ornithologists about the dangers of bread, which often refer to the same myths. Alas, people remain people, and many are susceptible to the 'duckling syndrome'! And a much larger number of people lack personal experience.
Fortunately, I have such experience and I am sharing it with you! I also always strive to support my knowledge with scientific data from those specialist scientists who have not only theoretical experience but also extensive practical experience. I call such people 'workers on the ground.'
Our grain balls consist only of real and very beneficial ingredients for forest birds. If you add white bread to them, be sure to dry it, ensure it is fresh, and use it only sparingly as a binding element.
There is definitely nothing harmful about it for our feathered friends!
© PAVEL PASHKOV
Climate WeaponsIn Climate Weapons, I examine human attempts to influence the climate and their possible consequences for nature. This book is my gift to you: download it free, read it and pass it on.Read for free
Support the fight!
Your support makes it possible for me to continue my independent work. I run these projects independently of government and business. Stand with me and support my mission to protect wildlife.
I want to support!Ancient Forest
I launched an independent project to protect Russia’s forests — an analytical research center focused on the scale of destruction of intact forests, wildfires, and the pressures threatening wildlife populations.
Explore the projectTFET Concept
I believe the global protected-area system must change and Territories of Full Ecological Tranquility (TFET) must be created. Wildlife needs refuges from human pressure! This is one of the key paths out of the planetary ecological crisis and toward preventing further ecosystem collapse.
Learn more